evaluator; distance from a lab: 1
MLCommons
Scorecard
Industry consortium producing the AILuminate safety benchmark.
Consortium, San Francisco, US. Confidence med. Domains: benchmarks, assurance. Scores by preset: Lab procurement 59; Regulator or auditor 60; Public trust 55; Equal weights 60. Weakest dimension: funding 1/4.
What would move the score. Published funding shares and a hazard suite the members do not see in advance.
Funding 1/4
Material revenue or investment from evaluated labs or their investors.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 1 on funding given the cited signals. Curator disclosure (2026-09-15): the curator holds small public-market shareholdings in Google and Meta. This evaluator has a confirmed ledger tie to Google (founding participation row T63; not a grant). Per the disclosure Rule, this assessment is flagged for public review: the rationale names the holding so readers can weigh it, and any reader can file a correction through the contribution path.
- Funded by member companies, including the labs whose models are benchmarked.
MLCommons AI Safety / AILuminate (MLCommons, 2026) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14
Governance 2/4
For-profit or PBC with a published COI policy.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 2 on governance given the cited signals.
- Consortium governance by members.
MLCommons AI Safety / AILuminate (MLCommons, 2026) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14
Personnel 2/4
Frequent two-way hiring; recusal on request.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 2 on personnel given the cited signals.
- Working groups staffed by member-company employees.
MLCommons AI Safety / AILuminate (MLCommons, 2026) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14 - President is a Google senior staff engineer; members include the frontier developers whose models are benchmarked.
evaluators.csv (24 evaluators: Coefficient and SFF totals, lab money, government contracts, leadership) (Kevin Bass (GitHub), 2026-09-14) tier 2 ledgerunverifiable2026-09-11
Access depth (lab-granted) 2/4
Pre-release with safeguards off or extended time.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 2 on access given the cited signals.
- Used as neutral ground in the AVERI double-blind pilot.
AVERI Pilot Report: The World's First Double-Blind Evaluation of a Proprietary Language Model (AVERI, 2026-08) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14
Scope control 3/4
Evaluator sets scope and can add questions.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 3 on scope given the cited signals.
- Benchmark design set by working group.
MLCommons AI Safety / AILuminate (MLCommons, 2026) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14
Publication rights 3/4
Publishes; redaction limited to security; redactions disclosed.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 3 on publication given the cited signals.
- Publishes results.
MLCommons AI Safety / AILuminate (MLCommons, 2026) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14
Method transparency 4/4
Open code, tasks, reproducible runs, factsheets.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 4 on methods given the cited signals.
- Open benchmark specification and methodology.
MLCommons AI Safety / AILuminate (MLCommons, 2026) tier 3 selfconfirmed AVERI Pilot Report: The World's First Double-Blind Evaluation of a Proprietary Language Model (AVERI, 2026-08) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14
Role incompatibility 3/4
Tools are open or free to the ecosystem.
evidence: tier 3 (self)
Anchor 3 on products given the cited signals.
- Benchmarks free to use.
MLCommons AI Safety / AILuminate (MLCommons, 2026) tier 3 selfconfirmed2026-09-14
Traced money and ties
hop 0: 1 row. Confirmed rows: 1 of 1. Dollar sums: confirmed + unaudited USD rows only; imported figures are not re-derived and never summed. Second hop traced for 1 of 1 sources. Ties: none within two steps recorded. Bounded negatives on file: 1.
Ledger
Money in
- T63 from Google / Google DeepMind: partnership undisclosed, . founding participation; no contribution amount disclosed confirmedtier 3 selfhttps://mlcommons.org/about-us/
Bounded negatives
- N13 no grant from Coefficient Giving in its index [Coefficient grants index, 2,911 rows, snapshot 2026-09-11] importedhttps://coefficientgiving.org/grants/
Roles hosted
- R52 Peter Mattson: principal. president; imported kevinnbass/metr-money-figure:EV17 importedhttps://mlcommons.org/about-us/leadership/
One hop away
Funding graph, focused
Neighbours at full strength, everything else faded. Hover any name to move the focus; click a name to open its page.